Bouldering Colorado Slideshow with Bob Horan

by Tom Markiewicz on October 3, 2008

Neptune Mountaineering in Boulder hosted a slideshow last night presented by Bob Horan, author of the new and highly controversial guidebook Bouldering Colorado.

Honestly, I was hoping some of the book’s most vocal detractors would show up for an open debate (hopefully more entertaining than the VP debate happening simultaneously), but there was a relatively small turnout of about 20 people and no visible outrage.

The slideshow was nicely prepared and ran about 1.5 hours consisting of photos (mostly of Bob) with some occasional video footage. Many Colorado bouldering areas were covered with an obvious heavy focus on Front Range bouldering. Included were a few areas in the slideshow that Bob said were actually not in the book (Rabbit Mountain near Lyons was one I asked about).

After the show I spoke with Bob and specifically asked him his thoughts on the issues brought up by some respected Colorado boulders like Peter Beal and Jamie Emerson. As a new resident to the area, I had no agenda other than to get some response from Bob in person as opposed to his not exactly tactful response on his Falcon blog.

He was very accommodating and made the following comments regarding the issues:

  • The original draft of the manuscript was double what was actually printed for the final book.
  • The manuscript was done about two years ago.
  • He said that the only ones complaining were the few elite climbers that had the opportunity to comment, but never spoke to him or provided input. (This is highly debatable though as it’s unclear whether these climbers were actually aware of the project.)
  • Bob said that there will always be mistakes and issues with any guidebook.
  • He also stated that the vast majority of climbers will benefit from the book.

While I disagree with how this entire situation was handled, Bob appeared to be genuinely concerned about writing a high quality guidebook. He made it clear to me that he was open to correcting any mistakes for future editions, but it’s still unclear why this wasn’t done more prior to publication as opposed to after it.

In a nutshell, I think this is what bothers most critics of the book and offers a learning lesson for other guidebook authors. As much as possible, guidebook publishers and authors need to provide an open forum to discuss a new work especially one with previously unpublished areas and those with questionable access. This would go a long way to getting the support of the local climbing community which in turn is the best free marketing you can get.

While Bob mentions this was done, there’s no excuse to not distribute this information well in advance to climbing site and prominent bloggers. I know if contacted, many of us would have been happy to publish information regarding the book years ago. Reading Bob’s most recent post on the subject, I really start to wonder how much blame lies on Falcon as well. Bob discusses how interacting with blogs and Internet media is new to him. But it is most definitely not out of the question to think that Falcon understands how publishing and marketing via Internet channels works.

To me, that is the biggest surprise of this whole issue. Regardless of the possible errors and judgement calls on including certain areas, at the ending of the day they are marketing a book. And a book we can only assume that they’d like to make a profit. Word of mouth and reviews (both print and Internet) will most definitely influence the sales of a guidebook when there are alternative options. With respect to bouldering in Colorado, this is most definitely the case.

As for the book itself, I have only skimmmed it and once I obtain a copy will write a full review after having time to thoroughly examine it. The one striking feature I will mention, and likely reason for the high cost, is the number of full color pictures of problems throughout the book. No one will argue the quality production value of Bouldering Colorado.

I know this issue has been discussed elsewhere, but I invite comments on this especially ones that help us all look to the future of how a situation like this can be avoided.

  • Rocky

    Pretty silly whining from newbies. In all the history of guidebooks, there has never been a perfect one. If every author and publisher waited for every nobody to get off their lazy butts and give inputs, nothing would ever get printed. I’ve looked over the book, and have no connection whatsoever, and will buy a copy when I can. Ultimately, books like this help spread impacts since people explore more. The NIMBYs have been proved wrong time and again when their pathetic cries about disclosure of “secret” areas went unheeded. Often as not, the areas were known ages ago and just never recorded.

  • peter beal

    None of this is whining from newbies or about “secret areas”. It’s about launching a big guidebook without checking in with your peers on the facts. The areas of controversy were certainly not developed “ages ago” given the high standard of the newer problems. If you want to spend 50 dollars on a potentially erroneous book, that is an option. However errors are what reviewers and editors are supposed to catch first so the buying public doesn’t have to. That wasn’t done for this book, plain and simple.

  • peter beal

    Visit my blog for a review of the book. The number of factual errors is staggering.

  • phil

    It sound like you could be a little jealouse of the book.
    How long have you been doing this???

  • Divorce Attorney Denver Colorado

    397294 242768Merely wanna state that this is extremely beneficial , Thanks for taking your time to write this. 515923

  • no fault doctor

    Hello there! I just would like to offer you a big thumbs up for the excellent info you have got here on this post. I am coming back to your web site for more soon.

  • view ebonyhomos com

    Aw, this was an extremely good post. Finding the time and actual effort to produce a really good article… but what can I say… I hesitate a lot and never seem to get nearly anything done.

  • シャネルのようなバッグ

    あの時、私も本人を前にバラされて焦ったもの。 彼が気付いてなくてよかったけど、別の意味で勘違いはさせていたみたい。 「その相手、初めは貴也だって誤解していたんだ。好きな男の子をめぐりあったとか?」 「そうそう。今は私の彼氏なんだけど、これがまた普通の子なの。俺と言う存在について――。 「明彦。お前は僕達の本当の子供ではないんだ」 「えっ?冗談じゃないから厄介なのよね」 男らしさとか、そういうのとは無縁の兄貴。 だからこそ、彼に興味を抱く女子も多い。 見た目もそうだけど、兄貴は女性が苦手なくせに女性に優しい。意識せざるを得ない、これもまた不思議な気持ちだ。 ここ数日の俺はいつもの調子が出ずにいる。 昼休憩に食事をしながら俺は凛子に相談をしていた。

  • truth about cellulite scam

    I’ve Googled around but no luck yet. The ones I’ve come across so far all have to do with MP3s, software and what not. If you have any in mind, please provide links to the sources. Many thanks in advance!.

  • Herbal Supplements

    I needed to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoyed every bit of it. I’ve got you book marked to check out new things you post…

  • penny stock

    I’ve always had internet explorer and I never used anything else. What can google chrome and firefox do that internet explorer cant?.

  • penny stock egghead

    If somebody like Julia Roberts or Natalie Portman had a personal blog where they posted pictures of their vacations or something, would you still take them seriously as actors? Do you think celebrities with personal blogs are less credible and taken less seriously than those who don’t? Furthermore, would you visit their blogs to see what they are up to?.

  • Jeannie Middendorf

    I truly appreciate this post. I’ve been looking all over for this! Thank goodness I found it on Bing. You have made my day! Thank you again!

  • falling dreams

    you are in reality a just right webmaster. The website loading velocity is amazing. It seems that you’re doing any unique trick. Moreover, The contents are masterwork. you have performed a wonderful activity in this topic!

  • Mild Herpes

    Hey! This really is kind of off subject but I want some advice from an established blog. Is it difficult to set up your personal blog? I’m not very techincal but I can figure items out pretty quick. I’m thinking about creating my own but I’m not sure where to start. Do you have any tips or suggestions? Cheers

  • Keith Watry

    Hi there! I could have sworn I’ve been to this blog before but after browsing through some of the post I realized it’s new to me. Anyways, I’m definitely happy I found it and I’ll be book-marking and checking back frequently!

  • Auto approve list

    I enjoy the efforts you have put in this, thank you for all the great blog posts.

  • forzamilan

    Dead indited subject pertinent , be pleased about it for information .

  • Talitha Yurman

    As soon as I noticed this web site I went on reddit to share some of the love with them.

  • Kredyty przez internet

    I’m impressed, I must say. Really not often do I encounter a weblog that’s each educative and entertaining, and let me let you know, you could have hit the nail on the head. Your thought is excellent; the problem is something that not sufficient persons are talking intelligently about. I’m very happy that I stumbled across this in my seek for one thing regarding this.

  • Hugh V. Johnson

    Was Initially studying throughout . I recommend your content. Do announce significantly more of this theme ok. Thanks so much

  • Brenda E. Brown

    Turned Out To Be reading around . I prefer your concepts. Do announce significantly more of this concern ok. Thank you

  • John J. Bouldin

    It really is practically close to impossible to find well-educated people on this matter, regrettably you look like you comprehend the things that you’re writing on! Appreciate It

  • Donald R. Evers

    Has Been browsing around . I’m keen on your concepts. Do announce more of this matter ok. Appreciate it

  • Phyllis R. Lovett

    We really hope to share it with you in which I’m really new to writing and extremely loved your webpage. Quite possibly I am prone to store your webpage post . You simply have magnificent article subject. Love it for sharing with us your domain report.

  • Douglas K. Busch

    I just need to share it with you that I am raw to putting up a blog and clearly liked your write-up. Likely I am prone to bookmark your article post . You simply have outstanding article topic. Be Thankful For it for share-out with us your domain post.

  • Ann J. Wells

    It really is near unattainable to encounter well-updated visitors on this matter, nonetheless you look like you comprehend exactly what you’re posting on! Thanks A Lot

  • Thomas E. Hubbard

    Was In Fact examining around . I want your ideas. Do publish somewhat more of this topic ok. Thank you

  • bmw 325d f30

    Hello for a superb study I am experiencing deliver with the rss though? Don’t identify why Not capable to subscribe to it. Is near any person getting identical rss problem? Anyone who knows kindly respond. Ta

  • livescore \u002f

    Very nice post. I by all means appreciate this website. Hold back writing!

  • Pingback: more information

  • immobilien dominikanische republik

    I cannot thank you fully for the blogposts on your internet page. I know you placed lots of time and effort into all of them and hope you know how considerably I appreciate it. I hope I will do precisely the same for an additional individual at some point. Palm Beach Condos

Previous post:

Next post: